Banter Return Policy 2025 | 30-Day Refunds & Free Returns

Banter Return Policy 2025 Guide: Refunds, Exchanges & Holiday Rules

Buying jewelry is often an emotional experience, whether it’s a gift for someone special or a treat for yourself. But sometimes, the piece just isn’t the right fit. If you are looking to return or exchange an item, understanding the Banter return policy is the first step to getting your money back without stress.

This guide covers everything you need to know about the 2025 policy, including the strict 30-day refund window, the generous 90-day exchange period, and how to handle returns for online vs. in-store purchases.

Note: All information is verified as of November 2025.

Banter Return Policy Overview

If you are in a rush, here is a quick snapshot of the current rules.

Return Window & Eligibility

To ensure your return is accepted, you must act within the specific timeframes Banter has set. The clock starts ticking differently depending on how you bought the item.

30-Day Refund Window

For a full refund to your original payment method, you have a return window of 30 days.

• In-Store Purchases: 30 days from the purchase date.
• Online Orders: 30 days from the date the item shipped.

90-Day Exchange Window

One of the best features of the Banter exchange policy is the extended timeframe. If you miss the 30-day refund cutoff, you still have time to swap the item. You have 90 days from the purchase or ship date to exchange your jewelry for something else.

Eligibility Checklist

Before heading to the store or packing a box, make sure your item meets these standards:

• Valid Receipt: You must have a receipt or packing slip.
• Condition: Items must be in original condition. They will be inspected by the Quality Assurance team.
• Documentation: For mail returns, you must include the packing slip and all original documents (instructions, warranties, etc.).

How to Return Items to Banter

Banter offers flexible options for returns, but there are specific rules for online versus in-store purchases.

Option 1: In-Store Returns (Fastest & Free)

This is the recommended method because it is free and you avoid return shipping delays. You can return both in-store and online purchases at any local Banter location.

1. Locate your nearest Banter store.
2. Bring the item in its original packaging.
3. Bring your valid receipt or the packing slip that came with your online order.
4. The associate will inspect the item and process your refund or exchange immediately.

Option 2: Online Returns by Mail

If you purchased your item online, you can return it by mail. Note: In-store purchases cannot be returned by mail.

Step-by-Step Mail-In Process:

1. Prepare the Package: Place your item securely in the original box.
2. Include Documents: Put the original packing slip inside the box.
3. Mark the Reason: On the packing slip, fill out the "Return Reason" column so Banter knows why you are returning it.
4. Label the Box: You have two options for labeling:
   • Free Mail-In Option: Check the Banter website to initiate a free return if available for your order.
   • Pre-Printed Label: Your packing slip comes with a label addressed to "SJIX-Processing Banter Returns." Warning: This label is usually not prepaid. You will need to pay for postage at UPS, FedEx, or USPS.
5. Ship It: Drop the package off at the carrier matching your label.
6. Save Your Tracking: Always keep the receipt with the tracking number until your refund is confirmed.

Refund Methods & Processing Time

Patience is key when waiting for a refund method to process, especially for mail-in returns.

• Refund Form: Money is returned to the original form of payment. If you used a credit card, it goes back to that card.
• Processing Time:
  • Once Banter receives your mail return, it takes 10–14 business days to process.
  • After processing, it takes another 5–7 business days for the funds to appear in your bank account.
  • Total Wait: Expect roughly 3 weeks from the time you mail your package.
• Promotions: If you bought items with a discount (e.g., "Buy One Get One 50% Off"), your refund will be prorated. You won't get the full price back if keeping part of the bundle invalidates the discount.

Banter Exchange Policy

If you love the style but need a different size, or if you want a completely different piece, the exchange process is very customer-friendly.

• In-Store Only: Exchanges must be done in person at a Banter store. You cannot process an exchange by mail.
• Time Limit: You have up to 90 days to make an exchange.
• Value:
  • If the new item costs more, you pay the difference.
  • If the new item costs less, you may receive store credit or a partial refund (if within the 30-day refund window).

Non-Returnable & Restricted Items

Not everything can be sent back. To avoid a rejected return, check this list of non-returnable items:

• Gift Cards: These are final sale and cannot be returned for cash.
• Personalized Items: Any jewelry that has been engraved, customized, or altered is final sale.
• Altered Items: If you had the item resized or repaired by a third party, the warranty and return policy are void.
• Piercing Earrings: For hygiene reasons, piercing earrings (used in-store for piercings) are generally non-returnable once the package is opened or used.

Note on Leasing: If you used Progressive Leasing or Affirm, you can still return items within 30 days. However, any interest you have already paid to the financing company is usually non-refundable.

Fees, Deductions & Exceptions

The good news is that Banter is very fair regarding fees.

• Restocking Fee: There are no restocking fees for returning items, provided they are in good condition.
• Return Shipping:
  • In-store returns are always free.
  • Mail-in returns can be free if you use the specific free return option. However, if you use the pre-printed label on your packing slip without a prepaid designation, you are responsible for the shipping cost.
• Shipping Charges: Original shipping fees (what you paid to get the item delivered) are not refunded unless the item was defective or Banter made an error.

Holiday & Extended Return Policies (2025)

If you are shopping during the holiday season, you get extra time. This is perfect for buying gifts early without worrying about the strict 30-day limit.

• Eligible Dates: Purchases made between October 24, 2025 and December 24, 2025.
• Extended Deadline: You have until January 24, 2026 to return these items.
• Rules: The standard requirements (receipt, original condition) still apply. This extension applies to both refunds and exchanges.

Customer Support & Contact Information

If you have a complicated issue, like a lost receipt or a damaged item, it is best to speak to a human.

• In-Store: Visit any local store for the fastest help.
• Customer Service: You can contact the customer support team through the "Contact Us" page on the official Banter website.
• Live Chat: Look for the chat icon on the bottom right of the Banter website for real-time assistance during business hours.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I return items to Banter without a receipt?

It is difficult to return items without a receipt. Banter's policy strictly states a valid receipt is required. However, if you purchased online, your order confirmation email acts as your receipt. For in-store purchases without a receipt, the store manager may fulfill the request at their discretion, possibly offering an exchange or store credit for the current selling price, but this is not guaranteed.

How long does a refund from Banter take?

For in-store returns, the process is immediate, though funds may take a few days to show in your bank. For mail-in returns, the processing time is longer: allow 10–14 business days for Banter to process the return, plus an additional 5–7 business days for your bank to post the credit.

Can I return online orders in-store at Banter?

Yes! Returning online orders in-store is the best way to avoid shipping costs and get your refund initiated immediately. Bring your packing slip or order confirmation email with you.

What items are non-returnable at Banter?

You cannot return gift cards, personalized or engraved jewelry, or items that have been altered (like resized rings). Additionally, returns may be refused if the item is damaged or shows excessive wear.

Does Banter charge a restocking fee?

No. Banter does not charge a restocking fee for returns or exchanges.

How do I return a damaged or wrong item?

If you receive a damaged or incorrect item, contact customer support immediately. Do not just mail it back without notifying them, as they may provide a free prepaid shipping label and instructions to ensure you are not charged for the return shipping.

Can I return a gift to Banter?

Yes, you can return a gift. If you have the gift receipt, you can get a refund or exchange. If you do not have a receipt, you may be limited to an exchange or store credit, and you will need to visit a store to discuss your options.

Can I exchange an item by mail?

No. The exchange policy states that exchanges must be processed at a Banter store location. Mail-in services are for refunds only.

Disclaimer: Return policies may change at any time and can vary by location. Always confirm details on the official Banter website or with your local store. Information verified November 2025.

Found this helpful? Bookmark this page for the latest Banter return policy updates and check our other guides before your next purchase.